Today, I wanted to compare the players at various positions and decide which team has the edge. In looking at various positions (QB, RB, WR, OL, DL & LB, DB, Special Teams, Coaches) I looked at season statistics and how consistent the players have been. Without further ado, here's the comparison.
QuarterbacksBrian Johnson has not been expected to win games soley with his throwing ability, he only averages hrowing for 165 yards per game. That said, he and Max Hall have about the same efficiency. Johnson has a higher completion percentage, but Hall has thrown for more yards and more touchdowns. If Hall's shoulder is healthy BYU should have the edge in the passing game.
EDGE: BYU
Running BacksDarrell Mack has already run for nearly 1100 yards and scored 9 touchdowns. Ray Stowers has shown some ability to run the ball as well, but the Ute running game is pretty much Darrell Mack and he has been a great runner. BYU back Harvery Unga will most likely reach 1,000 yards on the season, as he now sits at 909 on the year with two games left. Unga also has 9 touchdowns on the year. Tonga has comparable numbers with Stowers, except that he has scored 8 times on the ground. BYU throws to their backs more with Unga gaining over 500 yards receiving, compared to only 113 for Mack. However, as far as running the ball goes, which often determines who wins this matchup (see more tomorrow in the numbers breakdown), the Utes have a slight edge.
EDGE: UtahWide ReceiversRichards, Godfrey, Wilson and Hernandez have all been good targets for Johnson and all have over 250 yards receiving on the year and all but one have multiple touchdowns. Again, the Utes have not had to pass as much in their games this year as BYU has. BYU's corps are led by Pitta and Collie, who both have nearly 700 yards on the year. Reed, Allen and Unga have all been solid as well and all have over 250 yards. BYU has more weapons and Hall can really spread it around and find the open receiver.
EDGE: BYUOffensive LineUtah averages more yards on the run per game, but the line has also surrendered 25 sacks on the year. Hard to argue with 168 yards on the ground per game though. BYU's line seems to have underacheived this year, but perhaps that is because Hall has really stepped up and they haven't had to rely on the running game like many people anticipated in the preseason. Still, the Cougars average 137 yards on the ground and the line has only given up 16 sacks on the season. Utah prefers the run and BYU the pass and the numbers support those strengths.
EDGE: EvenDefense Line and LinebacksThe Utes seem more vulnerable to the run, giving up 129 yards per game. However, they have also come up with 35 sacks and the run defense has been improving all year long with especially strong performances the last two weeks. BYU's D-Line may be the most underrated part of their team and the linebackers are the key component with their speed. They only allow 92 yards on the ground per game and they have come up with 24 sacks on the season. With the improved play of the Utes' defense this one is very close.
EDGE: EvenSecondaryThe Utes give up less than 200 yards in the air per game. The Cougars have not been as stellar, but since the Tulsa game, they have been fairly solid. The Cougars are banged up in the secondary and the edge goes the Utes.
EDGE: UtahSpecial TeamsThe Cougars special teams have team anything but special this year, except perhaps the return game. However, the other two areas have shown improvement and have not had the mishaps that plagued them earlier in the year. Still, Payne's six field goals pales in comparison to Sakoda's 18 field goals. Sakoda is the conference's best field goal kicker and considering how close these game are could very well be the difference. The Cougars have to hope for big returns from Collie and Mahuika and hope that Santiago and Payne are consistent and mistake free.
EDGE: UtahCoachingIt was easy to criticize Kyle Wittingham early in the year when the Utes started 1-3, but he has done a nice job rebounding by winning 7 straight. He seems very emotional and his team plays with lots of emotion. Credit goes to Wittingham and the Utes for not melting down against a weaker opponent after the 1-3 start. Overall Wittingham is now 23-13 with a 15-9 record in the MWC.
Bronco is the model of consistency and the team has really shown that over the last few weeks and the Cougars are also riding a 7-game win streak. Bronco has the Cougars' players and the fans "fully invested" and the sellouts and 11-game home win streak to prove it. Overall, Bronco is 25-10 with a 19-3 MWC record.
Dick Harmon wrote a good article in the DesNews comparing the two:
http://deseretnews.com/article/1,5143,695229223,00.htmlWith Bronco's superior conference record and better conference finishes both full seasons ('05 -2nd, '06 -1st) he gets the nod.
EDGE: BYU